I think I've mentioned before that I liked what the Cape Town Commitment had to say about contextualization. In particular, it has defined "insider movements" in a way that is very helpful as you will see below.
A couple important notes on that.
First, IMs are not just something that is the domain of the Muslim world. I praise God for this clarification, because the debate/discussion surrounding contextualization is clouded by it being too associated with Islam and reaching Muslims. There is just much more to it than that. Critics of insider movements often make the mistake of painting them all with the same brush as if all IMs were in the context of Islam and as if they all looked the same and agreed on the same points.
Second, it defines IMs as missional communities of Christ-followers who seek to obey the Bible. Thus, a so-called IM that isn't following Jesus, seeking to obey Scripture, or seeking to engage its cultural context isn't really what we are talking about.
In this way, the gauntlet is sort of laid out for those who have been so adamant in their opposition to IMs. James White is one of my favorite persons who has spoken out against them. And I mean that. I repost lots of stuff from James and rarely miss his podcasts. However, his blanket condemnations of IMs are, I think, unfair and unhelpful. I would ask Dr. White to consider the CTC definition below and explain what exactly he opposes. It isn't the Christ-following, small groups, or Bible focus. So it would have to be the continuing connections to birth communities and the idea of maintaining certain religious observances. Well, it is one thing to oppose the holding over of particular, named observances. It is quite another to throw all IMs under the bus. White ignores the possibility that there exist insider movements who are genuine, theologically orthodox, Christ-followers seeking to obey the Bible and reach their kinsmen. He ignores the fact that these people are often persecuted just as much as those do not pursue contextualization. So, not that James would likely read this, but I would ask that he pull back a bit on his broad condemnation of IMs.
Tomorrow, I will post the CTC statement in its entirety and tell you another reason why I think it is a good thing.
- Cody on Instagram
- Cody on Twitter
- Cody on Pinterest
- Cody on Facebook
- Cody's Speaking/Travel
- Trinity International
- Hindus & Yeshu Bhaktas (येशु भक्त)
- Diaspora Missiology
- Partnership Opportunities
- Lausanne Global Conversation
- Global Diaspora Network
- Endiro Coffee
- Goh Bright Future
- Move In
This Month's Best
Let me take the opportunity today to share with you all a question that I recently received from a friend engaged in work among South Asian ...
Recently, a video of mine that was long ago posted on YouTube received a concerned, yet graciously written, comment (BTW- Another visitor...
The following brief clip has been dubbed "Piper Responds to the Insider Movement". I have noticed it being kicked around the inte...
Propaganda Piece by @SwarajyaMag Falsely Claims 80% of Bhutanese Refugees have Converted to ChristianityImage credit: Swarajya Magazine [NOTE TO READERS: I have just changed the settings on my blog to disable anonymous comments. I know t...
Photo Credit: Unknown ( Contact me ) I seriously like Jews. I mean, I'll pass on the Manishewitz, but in general, wow, I love th...